guitan11's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Chaotic Battle Part 1]

i give you props for creativity. however, the whole thing was a bit confusing. we could tell that it was a fight, duh. but what im saying is that it wasnt clear HOW they where fighting. lots of flashes and old-school sound effects, but i coulnt really see fighting moves besides that cool round house kick you do.

NightmareCinemas responds:

thanks for the info i made it that way so that its chaotic so people need to watch it 3 times 1 for every character haah :D , but on part 2 i made it more visible on who is fighting who

[Goobers Arena]

NICE JOB! i loved this animation :D i read that people complained about the speed of the fights. granted it could have been a bit faster, but then you wouldn't be able to appreciate the detail in this piece. the expressions, the gestures, the damage that the stage took. and the thing that i liked the most was the showdown. not just because of the street fighter reference, but you could actually see the damage each fighter took and it had consequences. unlike sprite fights or stickfigure fights where they get stabbed and shot at and they keep fighting full power.

this video/game was awesome!

mexipino responds:

I appreciate that you understand what I was going for; See, that's my whole intention. I don't want to take away from any one of the kills, so I try and pace the action that way. A ton of detail was put into this piece.... it can't be passed off as "just another stickman fight," and that's why I feel that the animation's pacing works. Glad that you also appreciated the damage they took and all the nuances of the animation; That's part of the reason that have the movie scaled to 700x700

[Stickfight Testing]

looks like you tweened at least 80% of this

nice idea. but the stickfigures seem a bit stiff. i mean, their limbs never bent once :/
just make their movements look more natural and you will make animations twice as cool as this one. :3

asas222 responds:

Thanks for comment... i know my mistakes... yeah it's sucks but i didn't make this animation with flash... i used a program named TIFSAT to make stickman fight... and i'm a kind of "Newbie" using this program.. lol :3

[Rock beats]

LOVE IT!

i really enjoy the simplicity of it and also the awesome pictures. they where not the best looking pictures, quality-wise, but that i think that it worked better for this animation. really funny stuff :D

AntonyC responds:

Hey that's neat. Thankyou!

[The Stick Crew Promo]

needs a hook

the music was cool, but the truth is that this promo didn't say much about what the series is about. you just introduced the characters. give me something that makes me want to watch your series! :D

Dan12905 responds:

I will, thanks for the advice
:)

[Stick Ninja Practice]

i see a future with you

the animation was not that good. but i can see that you at least have the imagination to and the potential to grow. your next animation HAS to be better. every animation you make has to be better than the previous one ;)

filip4e25 responds:

Thanks :) and it will be better :)

[Funky Stick Fight 3]

this one was great too

i noticed that you really played on what the music was doing for this one. the other ones were cool, but this one had more.... dance XD great animation, really enjoyed your work and i hope that you don't stop animating for good :D

hikuihito responds:

Thanks for the support!

[Benjamin Vs Nemesis]

what was your frame rate?

the video was not bad, but it seemed a bit choppy at parts. maybe by rising the frame rate you'l get a smother look to the animation. also, next time, dont do such a one sided fight. mix it up, and at the end destroy the competition ;)

poppetje3D responds:

The framerate was 24

[Spider Bite]

great! :D

the whole thing was a bit slow, but the punch line at the end really took it home XD
next time make the people act a bit more natural, not as stiff.

you just got a 5/5, 8/10 :D

MichaelJ responds:

It's supposed to be slow, Scott is supposed to be kind of dumb, and Mark is really nervous around Scott.

[Ultra Combos: Ryu 2]

naaaaa...

it was short. and there was no counter attack from ken! what kind of rivalry is that!? make it more interesting by having AT LEAST some sort of attempt to fight back. oh, and ken is my favorite character so that took a star away from you :3

WUGPanda responds:

um, if ken was your favorite character, and if you know street fighter 4, then you would know that ken had no chance to counter attack. this is a 2d rendering of sf4 not an original ( i will do one soon ) =D